But the spirit does not only work in a kenotic manner, but his very nature is kenotic. Recovers a major but neglected concept drawn from pauls letters, that underlies theories of subjectivity across a wide range of western thought, from medieval mysticism to hegel, to bataille, confounding the. Literally emptying in greek, kenosis is a theological notion signifying the christian belief that in the life and death of jesus of nazareth god empties out the divine selfhood in humble selfgiving love to the world. Biblical ground, for the new testament writings undoubtedly teach a kenosis of some kind in their doctrine of the incarnation. Speaking of both christs divinity and humanity, the apostle john writes, in the beginning was the word, and the word was with. Kenosis in christology christology is the study of the work and the person of christ. The selflimitation of god father, son, and holy spirit. Key concepts hegemonic masculinity patriarchal dividend. A brief history of the kenosis theory the heidelblog. What we celebrate at christmas ligonier ministries.
Kenotic theory can possibly reconcile the prohibitionist. Hypostatic union and kenosis of christ, doctrine of. Did the baby in the manger know that the world was round. Battered hearts and the trinity of compassion 53 universe and has made satisfaction for all. A principle of divine kenosis or condescension in some sense lies at the heart of any incarnational christology. The use of the term development to refer to national economic growth emerged in the united states beginning in the 1940s and in association with a key american foreign policy concern. Caring for creation introduction charles darwins theory of evolution brought to full fruition, a tension between two views of the world. If jesus was not fully divine, then his atoning work would not be sufficient to atone.
President, adventist theological society presidential address for the joint meeting of the adventist theological society and the adventist society for religious studies chicago, il november 16, 2012 2012theme. Kenoticism, also known as kenotic theology or kenotic christology, is an unbiblical view of christs nature. These attributes were omniscience, omnipresence, and omnipotence. The editor and several of the contributors to this volume c. Kenotic mysticism and servant leadership in the letters of. A biblical and theological answer to the false doctrine of kenosis introduction an increasingly prevalent teaching in evangelical circles, particularly in charismatic circles, is the doctrine of kenosis. When it comes to the kenosis, we often focus too much on what jesus gave up.
Kenotic theology is a theology that focuses on the person of christ in terms of some form of selflimitation by the preexistent son in his becoming man. Christ did this voluntarily so that he could function as a man in order to fulfill the work of redemption. The theory of influence before we discuss the poetic influence of t. The situation is very clearly revealed in the classification of the possible christological schematizations which otto kirn gives us in his elements of evangelical. While the term is found in a number of patristic writers and formed a key point of controversy between the lutheran theological faculties of tubingen and giessen in the 17th century, kenoticism is usually associated with a group of german theologians in the mid19th century. The term kenosis comes from the greek word kenoo, translated emptied in chapter 2 of pauls letter to the philippians. At face value, it is amazing that god in the world could just be ignored, but this is in fact the case. One of the great mysteries contained in the bible is that it teaches that jesus is fully god and also that he is fully man.
Warfield, the great scholar at princeton, in remarking on the kenotic theory of his day said, the only kenosis that that theory proves is the kenosis of the brains of the theologians who are propagating it. The kenosis theory states that jesus gave up some of his divine attributes while he was a man here on earth. Ward, associate professor of theology, southern baptist theological seminary, louisville, kentucky, received his general and theological education at ouachita college, ouachita, arkansas b. The key to writing about theory is to read and fully understand the argument that the theorist in question is making. The life of christ subsequent to his birth in bethlehem reveals the same normal human development and growth. His dissertation, the functions of social conflict, took conflict theory in a new direction and was later named as one of the bestselling sociology books of the twenti. The term kenosis refers to the doctrine of christs selfemptying in his incarnation. Unfortunately, in the application of this valid principle, men failed to keep their eyes steadfastly upon the historic person. Prose, on the other hand, is not only more accessible, but also doesnt necessarily require you to. The doctrine argues that jesus gave up some of his divine characteristics when he was on earth in the flesh. The kenotic theory, which tried to find a middle ground between the godman and the merelyman jesus, having passed out of sight, the field is held by pure humanitarianism.
Wendts theory is not a theory of the incarnation at all, but rather as r. Kenosis therefore is a paradox and a mystery since emptying oneself in fact fills the person with divine grace and results in union with god. By resort to a kenosis theory gore was able to argue that errors in matters of fact need not in the least impugn christs moral perfection. Cooke, a methodist writer, says the incarnation and recent criticism, new york. The word kenotic is derived form the greek word kenoo which means to empty, richard muller define kenotic christology as, emptying. The kenosis theory began to sound more and more like an acceptable way to say that in some sense jesus was god, but a kind of god who had for a time given up some of his godlike qualities, those that were most difficult for people to accept in. Who, although he existed in the form of god, did not regard equality with god a thing to be grasped, but emptied himself, taking the form of a bondservant, and being made in the likeness of men. Smith, one of the leaders of canadian poetic modernism and who has been described by w. Eaton and mains, 1907, a substitute for it of some kind of a divine inhabitation. It is to answer the question of why a good god permits the manifestation of evil, thus resolving the issue of the problem of evil. Gottfried thomasiuss view of kenosis in the first part of the 19th century, when ferdinand baur became professor of theology at germanys tubingen university, he following in the footsteps of g. Kenosis in orthodox theology is the transcending or detaching of oneself from the world or the passions, it is a component of dispassionation. Gottfried thomasius view of kenotic christology religion essay. Christology is an intriguing and vast subject in which kenotic theology is one study.
The spirit has been referred to as the selfeffacing, or shy person of the trinity, and certainly this is the case. Some theodicies also address the evidential problem of evil by attempting to make the existence of an allknowing, allpowerful and allgood or omnibenevolent god consistent with the existence of evil or. New, as the eliot of canada 12 it is a precondition to examine how the theory of influence has been promulgated by harold bloom in his celebrated work the anxiety. This false teaching is drawn from impure wells, it is dangerous because of the other false doctrines it leads to, and it flies in the face of the heart of christian teaching. These writers thought they could have it both ways, and welcome such current ideas without abandoning christian faith.
The selfemptying of god 3 recent years have witnessed a renaissance of interest in kenotic christologies among philosophers of religion in particular. Conflict and critical theories 215 united states and arrived in new york in 1941. Such a study seeks to interpret the significance and meaning of jesus christ for our own times in light of biblical and historical developments. When used of christ, the noun signifies the union of his two natures, the. Development theory, cluster of research and theories on economic and political development. The editor and several of the contributors to this. Stephen evans defends as religiously powerful and theologically legitimate, a kenotic theory of the incarnation, arguing that some kind of divine self.
In christianity, there exists a socalled kenotic doctrine kenosis. Dubilet is a very lucid writer who does an excellent job of explaining philosophically sophisticated material without oversimplifying. Development theory economics and political science. Having briefly surveyed various inadequate approaches to the nestorian controversy, the author shows that the protection of the unqualified divine impassibility from being compromised by any involvement in suffering was at the heart of theodores and nestorius christology. Gess 181991 and a group of british theologians in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. The kenosis theory is a dangerous doctrine because if it were true then it would mean that jesus was not fully divine.
In his life, he experienced similar feelings and limitations as other human beings. Kenoticism teaches that the divinity of the son of god was somehow lost or lessened when the lord took on human flesh and entered our world. The book also explores the implications of a kenotic view of the incarnation for philosophical theology in general and the doctrine of the trinity in particular, and it concludes with essays that examine the validity of the ideal of kenosis for women, and a challenge to traditional christology to take a kenotic theory. This interpretation of deity has been inspired especially by reflection on the life and crucifixion of jesus in whom christians believe the fullness of god resides. There is no original or primary gender a drag imitates, but gender is a kind of. Bill johnson of bethel church has made this selfemptying doctrine of jesus the very backbone of his teaching and ministry.
1669 430 1070 620 105 1471 606 878 673 3 804 187 1116 108 1317 1288 785 5 1009 720 1342 256 30 1449 817 969 1288 1232 977